Give every option the same design basis
Supply each bidder with a shared feed description: sludge origin, total and volatile solids, seasonal variation and previous conditioning. Identify grit, fibres and chemical additions. Specify average and peak dry-solids production in kg DS/day, available working hours and the receiving facility’s requirements. Wastewater flow through the treatment plant does not describe its dewatering duty.
For an arithmetic example only, 30 m³/day at 20 kg DS/m³ contains 600 kg DS/day. Processing this in six effective hours requires 100 kg DS/h and a feed flow of 5 m³/h. Start-up, cleaning and interruptions reduce the available production hours. Check hydraulic capacity and solids capacity separately.
Understand the operating differences
A belt press combines drainage with compression between porous belts and needs belt tracking and washing equipment. A centrifuge separates material in a high-speed rotating bowl, bringing vibration, wear and specialist maintenance into the assessment. A screw press slowly conveys and compresses conditioned sludge; filter geometry and adjustment arrangements differ between manufacturers.
These distinctions do not establish a universal winner. Request measured demand for the proposed package, declared noise with test conditions, ventilation needs and replacement access. A compact machine can still require substantial room for polymer preparation, tanks and component removal. Compare the installed arrangement rather than catalogue footprint alone.
Compare results achieved at the same time
Cake solids, capture, throughput and polymer dose must relate to the same stable operating period. A drier cake may bring little benefit if solids escape into the return liquor or throughput falls below the duty. State whether polymer consumption means active polymer or commercial product, and convert bids onto the same basis.
At an assumed 95% capture, a feed containing 600 kg DS/day produces 570 kg DS/day in the cake. At 20% cake solids this becomes 2.85 wet tonnes/day; at 25%, 2.28 tonnes/day. These are hypothetical equal-capture scenarios excluding reagent solids, not claimed results for any machine.
Choose against the annual operating requirement
Use parallel trials or representative equivalent sludge batches and record the settings. Compare installed annual cost, consumables, labour, cake management and return-liquor treatment. Include service access, replacement parts and an alternative route during outages. Select equipment that meets the site objective across a documented operating envelope rather than relying on its best isolated test result.
Common questions
Does a screw press always use less electricity than a centrifuge?
Do not assume this for the complete installation. Compare measured demand from dewatering, pumps, conditioning, washing and conveying at equivalent solids loads.
Should the driest cake win the tender?
Only when the disposal benefit and receiving-site acceptance justify the associated investment, consumables, capacity and availability. Maintain an agreed solids-capture requirement too.
