Define production, capture and the cost boundary
Specify annual tonnes DS, operating schedule, capture and cake solids fraction. Annual wet cake mass equals feed dry solids multiplied by capture and divided by cake solids fraction. Account separately for reagent-derived solids where relevant. Identify which items belong to the full line and which remain outside the comparison.
The example assumes 200 tonnes DS/year, 96% capture and cake at 20% solids, excluding reagent solids. Outputs are therefore 192 tonnes DS/year and 960 wet tonnes/year. These are modelling assumptions rather than performance figures for Neptuno or any particular press.
Calculate a reproducible operating scenario
Invented annual inputs for illustration: 6,000 kWh at €0.20/kWh costs €1,200; 1,600 kg of active polymer at €4/kg active costs €6,400; and 150 labour hours at €25/hour costs €3,750. Add assumed maintenance of €3,000 and 500 m³ of water at €1.50/m³, costing €750.
Managing 960 wet tonnes at an assumed combined charge of €70/tonne adds €67,200. Those items total €82,300/year: €411.50 per tonne DS fed, or approximately €85.73 per wet tonne. Convert polymer pricing onto an active basis; a price per kilogram of commercial emulsion cannot be used directly with the active-polymer quantity.
Test which variables influence the decision
Keeping capture and other assumptions unchanged, cake at 25% solids would produce 768 wet tonnes/year. At the same hypothetical management charge, this reduces that item by €13,440/year. This is mathematical sensitivity, not a guaranteed or cost-free improvement. Add any change in polymer, energy or throughput needed to achieve it.
Also test low-utilisation years, changing dry-solids production, cleaning time and minimum chargeable collections. Cost per tonne captured is another useful metric, but declare the denominator. Do not compare it directly with a quotation stated per tonne fed. Include any genuine downstream benefit or added operating burden on the same basis.
Extend operating expenditure into lifecycle cost
Add installed capital, construction, replacements, end-of-life work and return-liquor treatment or contingency costs within the agreed scope. Compare alternatives over the same horizon and using the same financial treatment of future cash flows. State discount rate and base year where present value is used. The example excludes capital, financing and return treatment, so it is neither a complete lifecycle estimate nor a project budget.
Common questions
Can measured main-motor electricity consumption represent whole-line use?
Only for that explicitly limited boundary. A nameplate kW rating alone does not establish kWh. A complete installation comparison includes measured or properly estimated energy for the relevant pumps, polymer preparation, washing and cake transport.
Is cost per wet tonne a reliable efficiency indicator?
It describes a logistics unit cost. For dewatering comparisons, relate it to dry solids, capture, cake solids and annual expenditure; additional cake water can distort the interpretation.
